Detective Pikachu Returns: An Immersive Mystery Game with Charm but Lackluster Mechanics
Nintendo Switch players can now dive into the world of crime-solving with Detective Pikachu Returns, a game that offers a simplistic yet charming experience. Developed by Creatures, the studio behind the original Detective Pikachu, this game is perfect for younger gamers and families. However, older fans may be disappointed by the game’s limited mechanics, predictable mysteries, and dated visuals.
The game follows the story of Tim Goodman, a college student who teams up with a Pikachu in a detective’s hat. Together, they form an unlikely duo of mystery solvers with the unique ability to understand each other. The central plot revolves around the mystery of Tim’s missing father, Harry, which adds intrigue to the game.
Detective Pikachu Returns features six adventures that progress through dialogue and deductions. Players collect testimonies, search crime scenes, and piece together information in their journal to solve each mystery. While the deduction system is reminiscent of the investigation segments in the Phoenix Wright series, the game falls short with oversimplified mysteries that lack challenge.
Despite its shortcomings in mechanics, the game shines in its charm. The titular Detective Pikachu surprises players with his gritty and authoritative voice, delivering dramatic remarks that emulate the classic noir formula. The animations and witty one-liners bring a smile to players’ faces, making the game enjoyable. Pikachu’s interactions with other Pokémon, such as riding a larger one in mini-game sections, add an extra layer of fun to the experience.
However, the game’s mechanics often feel underwhelming. The deduction system is predictable, with answers generally obvious before Tim and Pikachu catch up. The game relies on simple mini-games and quick time events, which fail to provide a satisfying challenge. Additionally, the game’s visuals fall short, lacking the detail to make characters look realistic.
Despite these drawbacks, Detective Pikachu Returns offers an immersive look into the Pokémon world. Players can explore the bustling streets of Rhyme City, gaining insight into the daily lives of its inhabitants. The game also tackles dark themes, such as divorce and police corruption, in a family-friendly manner, offering a thought-provoking experience for players.
While the game may not appeal to older Pokémon enthusiasts due to its simplistic mechanics and predictable mysteries, it serves as an excellent introduction to mystery games for younger players. Families looking for a game to enjoy together can also find satisfaction in Detective Pikachu Returns.
In terms of accessibility, the game lacks features for colorblind players and does not provide options to adjust text size or background. This is a disappointment, considering that it is a Nintendo title.
As a Pokémon fan and avid mystery game player, I spent 10 hours with Detective Pikachu Returns, playing through the majority of the mysteries and side quests. I experienced both the Japanese and English dubs to fully appreciate the voice-acting. While the game has its flaws, it offers a decent experience for fans of the genre.
For those seeking alternatives, our list of the best Pokémon games and the best RPGs can guide you in the right direction.
