Apple’s new FineWoven cases for the iPhone 15 have been receiving negative reviews from consumers and experts alike. YouTuber MobileReviewsEh stated that the FineWoven cases are inferior to Apple’s leather cases, while The Verge criticized the entire FineWoven accessory line as being “terrible.” Now, it’s our turn to weigh in.
After using a Pacific Blue FineWoven case on an iPhone 15 Pro for a week, TechRadar’s Senior Phones Editor and I share some of the same criticisms. However, I’m happy to report that Apple’s latest environmentally-friendly protection option isn’t a complete disaster, just a big disappointment.
To understand the context, FineWoven is part of Apple’s effort to prioritize sustainability and the environment. The “carbon-neutral” material is used in various MagSafe accessories, including cases and watch bands. While Apple still offers clear and silicone cases for the iPhone 15, FineWoven is positioned as the luxury option with a higher price tag.
Apple’s commitment to ethical and sustainable production is commendable. Unfortunately, this focus on sustainability has come at the expense of quality. The FineWoven material, touted as a “durable microtwill” with a suede-like touch, falls short in reality. It is easily scratched by keys or fingernails, and these scratches are highly visible and seemingly permanent. Apple claims that some scratches may diminish over time, but this provides little comfort to customers who have invested in a case that is both stylish and protective.
One major issue with FineWoven is its texture. It feels clammy in the hand, leaving the impression of sweaty fingers. While it doesn’t actually cause sweating, this sensation is unpleasant when holding the phone. Additionally, the material resembles the fuzzy fabric used to make Calico Critters or Sylvanian Families toys, not the suede-like feel Apple promised. Ironically, deconstructing a family of Calico Critters could potentially yield enough material to construct an Apple FineWoven case, at a similar cost.
However, not everything about the FineWoven cases is negative. Thankfully, the sides of the case are made of hard plastic, providing sturdiness and a comfortable grip. The metallic finish on the buttons adds a touch of sophistication, and they have a pleasant tactile feel. The cases also fit snugly onto the phone, offering a sleek look without adding bulk. The colors available are diverse and give off a premium vibe. Apple’s MagSafe technology works seamlessly with these cases.
To improve my FineWoven experience, I attached an old leather MagSafe wallet to the case, which addressed some of the issues I had with the material.
Although Apple’s move away from leather is a step in the right direction, the FineWoven cases as a whole fall short. The company is allowed a few missteps in its sustainable journey, but that doesn’t mean you should invest your hard-earned money in a subpar product.
